| Platinum | Backwoods Soap & Candle Company |
| Gold | Wishes |
| Silver | Backwoods Soap & Candle |
| Bronze | Cedar Ave Candle Co. |
| Top Pick | Blend Creative Vintage & Studio |
| Top Pick | Community Farm Store |
| Top Pick | Gi Gi's Gift Creations |
| Top Pick | Plentifill |
| Top Pick | The Ginger Room |
| Top Pick | Third Addition Gifts & Toys |