| Platinum | Original Udder Guy's Ice Cream & Candy |
| Gold | Drifters Creamery |
| Silver | Sweet Meadows Market |
| Bronze | Mizu Real Fruit Icecream |
| Top Pick | Cowabunga Cones |
| Top Pick | Italian Kitchen & Deli at Grove Hall Farms |
| Top Pick | Mountain Man Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Scoops By The Sea |
| Top Pick | The Glow Effect |
| Top Pick | West Coast Cones |