| Platinum | Moos Pizza |
| Gold | Alderlea Farm and Cafe |
| Gold | Little Town Pizza |
| Silver | Italian Kitchen & Deli at Grove Hall Farms |
| Silver | Romeo's |
| Bronze | Ali Baba Pizza |
| Top Pick | J & V's Burgers & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Quattro Bambini Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Sarpinos Shawnigan |
| Top Pick | Zzas Pizza |