| Platinum | The Red Balloon Toy Shop |
| Gold | Grace Kidz Thrift Store |
| Silver | Third Addition Gifts & Toys |
| Bronze | Freya-Sophia Waldorf Store |
| Top Pick | Brickity-Dooda |
| Top Pick | Kinderbeez Children Consignments |
| Top Pick | Lafa Brands |
| Top Pick | Scott's Toys & Hobbies |